Miami on the Record
Serving Miami, FloridaVol. 1, No. 9
Government & Elections

Historic board removes First Presbyterian annex and parking lot from Brickell landmark site

The Nov. 3 vote lets City staff approve demolishing the church's school annex after documentation, while keeping an advisory design review, a wider buffer and a salvage list.

ShareFacebookXEmail

MIAMI - First Presbyterian Church's landmark site on Brickell Avenue just got smaller.

On Nov. 3, Miami's Historic and Environmental Preservation Board voted 6-1 to take the church's school annex and parking lot out of the designated historic site, according to the signed resolution and the roll call on the City's official meeting video.

That means City staff can approve tearing down the annex and clearing the lot once the church files a documentation package, opening the land behind the church to new development.

The church building at about 609 Brickell Ave. stays protected; the annex and parking lot no longer are.

What the vote does

The board first designated the church in 2003, according to the City's staff analysis. The Nov. 3 resolution amends that designation and reclassifies the annex and parking lot as non-contributing, meaning they no longer count toward the site's historic value.

Staff may approve demolition of all or part of them without another board hearing, after the church provides a documentation package:

• a history report on the annex

• archival photographs

• as-built drawings

• a collection of historic plans and images

A board member who explained the motion's intent said support was based on the tower plans presented that night. Board member Emilio Bustillo cast the only no vote.

The church's side: give the sanctuary prominence

In its application, the church's attorney, Iris Escarra, wrote that it "requests a revision of the historic designation boundaries to give prominence to the masterful First Presbyterian Church building."

The application argues the annex was built later in a different, Mid-Century-influenced style that departs from the church's postwar Mediterranean Revival design and diminishes the church's historic prominence.

The applicants are the church and 13th Floor Key Church, LLC. At the hearing, the church's pastor said the annex "no longer meets our ministry needs" and that a partnership with 13th Floor and Key International would help sustain the ministry.

The neighbors' side: keep the whole site, to the bay

The Icon Brickell Tower 2 condominium association asked to join the case as an intervenor, a formal party that can contest the application.

The board denied that request in December 2024, when it first approved a similar boundary change.

The City Commission upheld the denial, but the 11th Judicial Circuit reversed both decisions and sent the case back, according to a summary given at the Nov. 3 hearing. The board then granted the association intervenor status 7-0.

In its presentation, the association asked the board to keep the annex and parking lot as contributing structures and to "keep the historic site boundary on all of Lot 2, up to the waterline of Biscayne Bay."

It argued that:

• the board got wrong or incomplete information in 2024

• the 2003 legal description covers the entire property

• removing the designation conflicts with the City's comprehensive plan

• the applicant never provided an endowment plan or recorded the covenant it promised

What protections remain

Design review. The church must offer a covenant on the land leaving the site. It gives the board purview "in an advisory role, to review any material exterior changes," such as scale, materials and articulation.

That review applies "upon Staff's determination that there has been a material deviation from the proposed plans" the applicant filed under PZ-25-20277.

A wider buffer. The space between the church's east wall and new development grows from 10 feet to 15 feet.

Salvage. At design review, the applicant must list architectural pieces salvaged from the annex and how they would be reused.

What happens next

The decision is final unless appealed to the City's Hearing Boards Division within 60 days of the Nov. 3 vote, according to the resolution.

Drafted by AI from the linked public source. Approved by a Daily News Editor.

Sources and documents